- All localities
- Compare
- New York, NY vs San Diego, CA
2026 editionEffective January 202658 locality pay areasData last changed 2026-08-25
New York, NY vs San Diego, CA: GS pay compared, 2026
The same grade and step pays $3,666 more a year in New York, NY. Whether that leaves you better off is a different question, and this page answers it.
That is how much more a GS-12 step 5 is worth in New York, NY than in San Diego, CA once local prices are counted. Here the bigger paycheck and the better outcome point the same way.
| New York, NY | San Diego, CA | |
|---|---|---|
| Salary on paper | $119,546 | $115,880 |
| Locality pay | 37.95% | 33.72% |
| Local price level | 112.6 | 111.9 |
| What it buys | $106,204 | $103,569 |
| Rank on paper | #2 | #6 |
| Rank by what it buys | #37 | #46 |
The first two columns are the salaries as published. The last column is the difference in what those salaries buy after local prices — positive means New York, NY comes out ahead, negative means San Diego, CA does. Cells marked ▲ have been cut to the $197,200 statutory ceiling.
| Grade | New York, NY | San Diego, CA | Difference after prices |
|---|---|---|---|
| GS-1 | 35,300 | 34,218 | +778 |
| GS-2 | 38,430 | 37,252 | +847 |
| GS-3 | 43,322 | 41,993 | +955 |
| GS-4 | 48,629 | 47,138 | +1,072 |
| GS-5 | 54,406 | 52,738 | +1,199 |
| GS-6 | 60,647 | 58,787 | +1,337 |
| GS-7 | 67,394 | 65,328 | +1,485 |
| GS-8 | 74,634 | 72,345 | +1,645 |
| GS-9 | 82,438 | 79,910 | +1,817 |
| GS-10 | 90,777 | 87,993 | +2,001 |
| GS-11 | 99,742 | 96,684 | +2,198 |
| GS-12 | 119,546 | 115,880 | +2,635 |
| GS-13 | 142,156 | 137,797 | +3,133 |
| GS-14 | 167,987 | 162,836 | +3,702 |
| GS-15 | 197,200 | 191,535 | +4,005 |
Step by step at GS-12
Comparing offers rarely means comparing the same cell. This is GS-12 across all ten steps in both areas, so a step 3 offer in one can be read against a step 7 offer in the other without arithmetic.
| GS-12 | New York, NY | San Diego, CA | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Step 1 | 105,481 | 102,246 | 3,235 |
| Step 2 | 108,997 | 105,655 | 3,342 |
| Step 3 | 112,513 | 109,063 | 3,450 |
| Step 4 | 116,030 | 112,472 | 3,558 |
| Step 5 | 119,546 | 115,880 | 3,666 |
| Step 6 | 123,062 | 119,289 | 3,773 |
| Step 7 | 126,579 | 122,697 | 3,882 |
| Step 8 | 130,095 | 126,106 | 3,989 |
| Step 9 | 133,611 | 129,515 | 4,096 |
| Step 10 | 137,128 | 132,923 | 4,205 |
The gap in the last column is the one on the offer letter. After local prices, $3,666 of extra salary at step 5 is worth $2,635 of extra purchasing power — about 72% of what it looks like. The rest is absorbed by the difference in what things cost.
Overtime is capped, and the cap differs
Under 5 U.S.C. 5542 an overtime hour is paid at one and a half times your hourly rate only while that rate stays at or below the hourly rate of GS-10 step 1 in your own locality. Above it, the hour is paid at the greater of your own rate and one and a half times that GS-10 step 1 figure — not both.
That threshold is a local number, so it differs between these two areas: $38.38 an hour in New York, NY against $37.20 in San Diego, CA. A GS-12 step 5 earns $57.28 an hour in New York, NY and $55.52 in San Diego, CA, and is paid $57.57 and $55.80 respectively for an overtime hour.
In both areas the overtime hour still carries a genuine premium at this grade. It stops doing so higher up the schedule, and sooner in the better-paid area.
The same money, a grade lower
Prices in New York, NY are higher, so a salary there does less work. The question that follows is obvious: what would you have to earn in San Diego, CA to be equally well off? These are the equivalents, at the same step:
- A GS-11 step 5 in New York, NY is matched by a GS-10 step 10 in San Diego, CA.
- A GS-12 step 5 in New York, NY is matched by a GS-12 step 6 in San Diego, CA.
- A GS-13 step 5 in New York, NY is matched by a GS-13 step 6 in San Diego, CA.
- A GS-14 step 5 in New York, NY is matched by a GS-14 step 6 in San Diego, CA.
Read that in the other direction and it is a negotiating fact: a move from San Diego, CA to New York, NY at the same grade is not a raise, whatever the offer letter says.
Where raises stop counting
No General Schedule rate may exceed Level IV of the Executive Schedule, $197,200 in 2026. Inside that band a step increase produces a bigger number in the formula, the law cuts it back, and the payslip does not move.
New York, NY has 6 of its 150 cells pinned to the ceiling; San Diego, CA has 4. The higher-paying area runs out of room first, which matters more over a career than the difference in any single year.
What each area covers
New York, NY is the New York-Newark, NY-NJ-CT-PA locality pay area, 37 counties. San Diego, CA is the San Diego-Chula Vista-Carlsbad, CA area. 1 counties. Locality follows your duty station, not your home address and not your agency headquarters, so a house on the wrong side of a county line does not change the rate — the building you report to does.
The full New York-Newark, NY-NJ-CT-PA table: every grade and step. The full San Diego-Chula Vista-Carlsbad, CA table: every grade and step. To put your own grade and step against either, use the pay calculator.